Piano Quartet in D minor Op. 25
Dora was born in Budapest to an aristocratic family. Her father was a Croatian count and her mother a Hungarian singer and pianist. This maternal influence was to guide Dora away from an unfulfilling aristocratic life into a more challenging musical future. A pseudo-biographical film “Countess Dora” was made in 1993.
Her musical education came from Zagreb, Dresden and Munich and she developed a wide circle of friends such as Rainer Maria Rilke, Karl Kraus and the pianist Alice Ripper. Some of her earliest compositions are songs and solo piano pieces. The Piano Quartet Op 25 was the first such for this combination. Previously Dora had made an arrangement of a piano impromptu and set it for Piano Quartet. In 1908 her D minor Piano Quartet Op 25 set her on a new track combining strings and piano in her early romantic style. She was 23yrs old.
Allegro ma non troppo The first movement is immediately engaging with long sweeping lines from the strings underpinned by pianistic energy.
Andante con moto A sweet rich opening gives way to interplay between the cello and viola while the piano ripples the harmonic skeleton alongside them. There is a simplicity here that belies the complexity of the whole quartet, however it acts as a contrast to the other movements in the accepted manner of the time.
Menuetto This is more tart and rhythmic at its opening. Predictability in the menuetto is saved by the repeat of the more spikey opening. Harmonically this movement is straightforward and has no surprises.
Rondo This combines all the stylistic elements of the early movements. Strings pass the themes to each other while the piano for the most part provides a rich accompaniment with flashes of thematic material. The quartet closes with a suitably dramatic cadence.
Robin Holloway b.1943
Piano Quartet Op 143 This is dedicated to Tom Poster and today’s performance is the World Première.
Robin Holloway is a well known composer. He studied English and Music at Kings college Cambridge. Composition tuition was taken from Alexander Goehr and Bayan Northcott. His doctoral thesis was on Debussy and Wagner. Cambridge is still home and throughout his working life he has taught composers such as Thomas Adès, Huw Watkins, Peter Seabourne, George Benjamin, Judith Weir and Jonathan Dove. Holloway’s own music has been summed up by David Matthews as being “formed by a productive conflict between Romanticism and modernism”. In addition Holloway has written numerous articles and book reviews.
Johannes Brahms 1833-1897
Piano Quartet No.1 in G minor
Brahms was born in Hamburg and was familiar with Beethoven and Bach’s musical sound-world. As a young man he made a name as a pianist where he made more money than as a composer with published scores. His repertoire was mainly Bach and Beethoven. Brahms is now known for having imposed classical order on his compositions which marked him out in the period of otherwise Romantic music. In 1861 the year of the composition of his G minor piano quartet Brahms was struggling for recognition as a composer. Now in Hamburg, Clara Schumann, 14yrs his senior, was sympathetic and performed the piece in Hamburg in 1861, the year of its composition.
Brahms had written violin sonatas for Joseph Joachim and trios and string quartets but the piano was so important that it was simply embedded into the string ensemble of violin, viola and cello. Brahms performed the piece himself in Vienna in 1862.
Allegro This is homophonic with regular phrase lengths. The piano is thoroughly integrated with the strings. The D major contrasting section gives way to a reprise of the G minor opening. The pianist composer is obvious here.
Intermezzo: Allegro ma non troppo Strings open this lilting dance-like movement. The piano swiftly joins in and the melody is shared. There is the beginning of Brahms’ use of 2/3 rhythm common to many later pieces. This movement is also in ABA structure and as such conforms to expectations. Brahms spells Clara’s name in the melody with C & A kept, but B & G substituting L & R. A short coda rounds off.
Andante con moto A broad balanced opening theme sets this up in E♭ major, a rich sounding key. Animato marks a shift to C major and a change of texture and mood which is martial and decisive in nature. The reprise is prepared then realised in E♭ with a fuller and more flowing texture. It closes with a measured relaxing phrase.
Rondo alla Zingarese Here is a real dance with plenty of rustic charm and virtuosic playing for his audience. Meno presto Now a bold slower tempo here as directed, but still it’s a dance. The mood relaxes briefly and then through a series of short sections teases the listener as false climaxes are reached and immediately dissolved. The pianistic dominance brings the whole quartet to a triumphant finish.
Helen Simpson

The violin gets to state the second theme (illustrated) whose opening (under x) is reused in the second movement. Towards the end of this genial and boisterous first movement Beethoven plays the false-ending trick – one that Haydn loved – before a long and novel final coda.
The Adagio slow movement is, unusually in a rondo form with the opening material (illustrated) alternating with new ideas. Its start (under y) has an obvious relationship to the x passage of the first movement.
the Scherzo we arrive at the boisterous Presto Finale which opens with a provocatively playfully jump of a tenth. More provocations follow – a slithery semitone descent perhaps cocking a snook at Mozart’s chromaticisms leading into a parody of Haydn’s Gypsy Rondo style. But the best is yet to come. After some daring modulations, the strings try to tip-toe away in a slow pianissimo semitone descent, but the piano leaps out at them blowing a giant raspberry (illustrated) and then skips away as if nothing had happened.
The difference is evident from the start: the work opens with the violin and cello playing the expansive main theme (illustrated) in octaves treating them as a single voice against the piano. In fact, all the other movements also open with the strings in octaves. Despite the increased power of the 1880s piano, and Brahms’ proclivity for dense chording, it is important to bear in mind that the Streicher piano that he was then composing at was considerably lighter in sound than a modern Steinway concert grand: “to hear Brahms’s music on an instrument like the Streicher is to realize that the thick textures we associate with his work, the sometimes muddy chords in the bass and the occasionally woolly sonorities, come cleaner and clearer on a lighter, straight-strung piano. Those textures, then, are not a fault of Brahms’s piano composition.” (Edwin Good).
Half-way through the movement Brahms plays a master stroke, the tempo notches up animato and the cello transforms the jauntily dotted opening phrase by slowing it in a heartfelt espressivo (illustrated) above ripples on the piano.
A further modification of the opening gives the theme for the variations of the second movement. The rising third (now A to C) is still there, but the original dotted rhythm is reversed into a ‘Scotch snap’ (as in ‘body coming through the rye’).
the end of the theme Brahms pulls a cunning technical trick: the two halves of the last 7 bars (illustrated) consist of a phrase followed by its inversion (rising intervals replaced by downward and vice versa). Such devices reflect Brahms’ thorough classical schooling (inversion of fugue subjects was a favourite baroque device), but using inversion to complete a melody looks forward, and perhaps contributed to Schoenberg’s famous view of “Brahms the Progressive”.
again starts with string octaves with the hallmark rising third, but this time in a fleeting pianissimo in C minor. It is gloriously contrasted in the slightly slower trio section by one of Brahms’ wonderful soaring melodies (illustrated) back in C major.
octaves and a rising third again start off the playful Finale – Allegro giocoso. The piano accompanies with a descending figure of repeated quavers (illustrated) which is extended and frequently recurs as a sort of laughing motif throughout this good-natured movement.
he opening two bars have the second violin simply setting the A-minor key but with the viola and cello providing an underlying threatening tremble. The first violin provides the theme (illustrated) which recalls one of Schubert’s songs ‘Gretchen at the Spinning Wheel’: “My peace is gone, My heart is sore, I shall find it never and nevermore”.
Two motifs shape the ensuing Allegro: it opens with a simple cadence (illustrated under 1), which after about 40 bars of tentative exploration leads to a joyful main theme as we finally get to the home key of C major (illustrated under 2). Only Beethoven could make such a movement out of these snippets.
contrasts with its assertive Trio in which the viola and second violin (written with Razumovsky in mind?), egged on by the others, lift the semiquaver runs of the Menuet and show just how far they can take them.
to give the start of the last movement’s fugue (illustrated). The viola, fresh from its triumph in the Trio, kicks off at speed for ten bars. Nobody is to be outdone, especially the first violin, who initiates a string-climbing competition, cheered on by the others. Finally, the second violin transforms the underlying slow accompanying figure into a lyrical vote of thanks and the party ends in a triumphant last fling.